Showing posts with label zara. Show all posts
Showing posts with label zara. Show all posts

Zara enters/should enter/should not enter India - Part 3

There are alredy 2 blogs written on this topic earlier. Assuming you’ve read them already, I’ll not waste time on the technicalities of the Zara model, and get to the point.

Should Zara (really) enter India or not? If you look at it in that sense, perhaps every other international brand should enter India. And why not? A sizable part of the population of India is under 30 years of age; disposable incomes are rising, so are aspirations, living standards, customer awareness, and all the economic lingo stuff.

But that’s not the point. Just because things are getting better in an economy doesn’t mean that we have graduated to any other brand/product in the world. As a primer to this statement, lets take the example of a microwave. I think about 7-8 years ago, microwaves were first introduced in India. I really don’t know when, but what I do know is that consumer acceptance of that product wasn’t exactly high. For any American, a microwave is a necessity. Probably an American can live without a stove for a while, but not a microwave. That clearly didn’t happen in India. Heating cold food and feeding it to the children was like a disgrace on a mother’s part.

Today, after such a long time, things are changing aren’t they? And mind you, they’re still in the changing mode. Microwaves still haven’t received absolute acceptance even after giving the consumer so much amount of time to graduate to one.

Same goes for Zara. We as Indians used to wear only traditional dhotis and salwaar-kamiz 80 odd years ago. The transition to the western clothing apparently began during the British rule. So firstly in absolute numbers we’re about 300 years behind the Europeans as far as fashion for western clothing goes.

Think about it; even today, if you wear your dad’s shirt and go out, no one would be able to point out that this is an ‘old cut’. The cuts, the stitching techniques have remained the same since a really really long time.

Think about women’s formals for instance. There’s an extremely short range of women formal shirts available in India. And mind you, I’m talking about the design and cuts, not the color of the shirt.

To put it in simple mathematical sense, this is how the 2 ideologies differ:

For Indian Fashion Industry its –
few cuts x lots of color variations

For the Zara Model its –
many cuts x very few color variations

And even if we take colors as a basis, even that sadly isn’t our strongpoint. We were shades of red in summer and wear shades of yellow during winter.

We wear linen in winter sometimes and synthetic materials in summers as well.

There’s no synchrony in us as far as colors, shades, cuts, fabrics go. We wear whatever we feel looks good on us. Every season, has its own shade, color swatch, designs, cuts etc. etc. We’re never so detailed as far as these attributed go. And the Europeans are extremely fetish about these minor details; the same way we’re fetish about cricket maybe.

Also, India follows a 2 season process; Summer/spring collection & winter/monsoon collection. While in Europe there are 4 different collections released for all the 4 different seasons.

Also, I don’t know how many of the readers have seen a Zara store, but Zara doesn’t play with colors a lot. It plays with cuts. And to save on its supply chain costs, you wont find colors other than white, black, grey, cream, red and a few more. Their color swatch is extremely limited, and their design swatch is much higher than an average Indian apparel outlet. You really think Indians will gladly buy only base colors and wear them, when they have so many other vibrant colors being offered by other apparel retailers?

Mango, one of the leading fashion wear brand for urban women has a few stores in India. The collection that it keeps on the Indian stores is one season old already in the International markets.

After reading all this some might see this as a drawback in us Indians, that we’re not so sensitive towards colors and cuts etc; that we haven’t graduated to these details like others have. But honestly are we supposed to graduate? Were shirts and trousers a part of our cultural heritage? We have our own saaris and salwar kameez. That’s where our forte lies. And that’s precisely the reason why Zara originated in Spain and not some shady town in India.

Zara has not been quite a success in the US, and for the simple reason that an average USUS, not in Europe. citizen wants clothing that is completely relaxed, functional and rugged. That’s why jeans were invented in the

Europe has its own fashion, US has its denim jeans, India has its bandhani.

Its seriously wrong for any of us to expect to graduate to the fashion sense that Europeans have. Simply because their definition of fashion is different than ours.

In Gujarati, there’s a saying, ‘gaam khase ke gaadu?’ (should the village move or the bullock cart?)

P.S. Thanks a lot to Sharimbal Kanishk (ex-Globus merchandiser & a NIFT grad) for all the info on Indian Fashion Industry.

ZARA into India – Part 2

I think a few pointers were missed in the earlier article regarding Zara, which I'm including here. I still am of the belief that Zara won't be the type that it is in the European region as far as India is concerned. So in short, I'm still not convinced about Zara being able to make a mark like it did at other places.

The reason why I felt that Zara just might not work is not only because of the population not being fashion centric. But in places like Europe, Zara is positioned as a mainstream brand. Something like our Killer Jeans and Spykar Jeans and the likes. Now in their lines, Zara will have to make its way through.

Also, because of its peculiar characteristics of keeping low amount of every SKU, there are no chances that Zara might ever come up with a discount scheme or an end season sale. So that's also a put off for an Indian. Zara's design team as well as the manufacturing facility is somewhere in Spain. Now we all know that the cost of manufacturing in the textile industry is the lowest in India and China. Given this situation Zara yet prefers to stick to Spain as its manufacturing hub. True, the plant is highly capital intensive requiring lesser amounts of labour than most conventional plants do. Yet, the very fact that the plant is in Spain means that the clothes won't be as economical as we have in India.

I agree that Zara could be a niche player, but then there too its entire business model stands of no use. I mean what's the use of changing your inventories every fortnight if the stocks aren't moving? What do you do with your old stock?

My only point here is Zara's business model can't be deployed on an 'as is' basis. And if it doesn't, I don't think there's much to gain in the Indian context, at least as of now.! The topic is laid to rest. (Commenters! Fire at will…!)

Zara's Entry to India.. What say u..?

In fact I wish to do quite a bit of research into this one. But however, this thought has been boiling in my belly since quite some time, so I’m putting it on the blog. Now for those who don’t know what Zara is; well as a primer, you can say that ZARA is one of the very prominent fashion brands especially in the European countries.

And since the era of retail dawns upon India, many brands have started shifting their faces towards the Indian sub-continent. Zara I believe must be one of them. I don’t have many news clippings to prove that they are seriously looking about foraying into India, but I’m sure they’re looking at the options.

Now allow me to tell what’s so special about Zara??? Typically, any firm that’s into fashion apparels follows a 12 month planning period. That means in any normal nicely running mill, Arvind Mills let’s say, starts its design phase for any particular season 12 months in advance. Thus, we can safely assume that the designers at Arvind Mills have begun the designing apparels for the summer of 2008. Cool no?

Well, for any layman this would sound like really hunky dory, but in real fashion terms, this 12 month-in-advance cycle actually sucks! And the reason is quite simple. Fashion is an ever changing phenomenon. And typically any fashion house can be called successful if it is able to respond quickly to the customers’ changing preferences with respect to fashion! And after knowing the kind of design cycle Arvind Mills follows, you certainly can’t call them as a responsive fashion house. In fact any fashion house of India can’t be called ‘responsive’ to consumer fashion preferences, since most of them follow the cycle that Arvind Mill does.

Thus, we can say that in India, it’s the fashion house that defines fashion for the people rather than the people determining what fashion should be! Quite eerie isn’t it? However, surprisingly, we don’t seem to realize the fact. And we quite easily accept what the fashion houses churn out for us.

This is where Zara comes in. Zara’s responsiveness towards the current fashion trends is as fast as 14 days max! That is, it senses the new fashion trends and is able to deliver designs pertaining to the upcoming fashion and hits the stores within 14 days! From fiber to fashion within 14 days! I think this is what we call as responsiveness.

How does this happen is sort of a complicated thing. It ranges from phone calls from every retailer to the head-office to online tracking of sales and stuff like that to a superb supply chain system. I won’t bore you on all this stuff, but my point is will this brand work if bought to India?

Let’s look at a few statistics to lure you into believing that it will work in India! Zara typically produces around 12,000 designs throughout the year, it produces designs in smaller quantities but produces a variety of designs. Which means lower quantity per design thus no off-season discounts or clearance sales necessary, and variety means more choices for the customer.

It is said that if you go to a Zara outlet and you like an apparel, the store attendant would prompt you to pick it up at that time only, since there are high chances that it would be sold out when you return back in a few days if you plan to pick it up later!

Also, there are around 200 designers who design the garments from fashion inputs received though phone calls from hundreds of Zara outlets every day. Ideally, there is an addition of 1-2 styles every week on a Zara portfolio.

After telling you all this, quite obviously you will tend to believe that Zara should certainly come to India isn’t it?

I say it shouldn’t. Here’s why.

One, there isn’t a sizable amount of population of India that changes its wardrobe every season. Most people don’t even really care about fashion specifics. In fact, there is a large part of the population that waits for the end season sale or the clearance sale to get their hands on the favorite brands. Fashion takes a back seat.
Thus, in this demographic build-up where people are not oh-so fashion crazy to change their pants every 3 weeks, the responsiveness, the 200 designers sitting in Spain and the supply chain counts for nothing at all.

You’re trying to give something to the consumer, and that too to a level he hasn’t matured.

Is it wise? I don’t think so.

What say??